Who should I pick for fantasy football running back, E. James or T. Barber?

Personally, if it was me, I'd take Tiki. You can't count on Edgerrin considering the Cards and how bad their offense is. He may end up being nothing more than a decoy for most of the season while whoever is playing QB throws lots of incompletions. At least with Tiki, you get a decent runner, and a fairly reliable (and much more durable) QB passing the ball to him.Who should I pick for fantasy football running back, E. James or T. Barber?
ok ive herd this question a million times edgerrin james is underated for sum dumb reason he is top 5 id take him b4 barber any day i dont even like tiki in the top 10 he is Overrated while james is gettin the bad shoulder take edgerrin james he has going to go for about 1,400 yards and bout 12-15td's trust me you will not be disapointed with him you will with tiki .Who should I pick for fantasy football running back, E. James or T. Barber?
I'd say tiki the cards o line is not the strongest and if he gets banged up he will sit he has no shame like that
well at first glance, one would say tiki barber. however, with eli a year older, and the receivers deeper and more talented, it seems an easy bet that he's not gonna carry the ball as much. also, he himself has stated that he is not the goal-line back, that will probably be brandon jacobs. so this adds up to fewer carries, fewer yards, and fewer tds. as for james, he has good receivers to stop defenses from stuffing the box, and a situation wthere they are probably going to try and work leinart into games, meaning he will get more carries, to take pressure off leinart. it can really go either way, but james is gonna be the workhorse, and with warner having health issues, they're gonna be running a bunch, so i'd go with him
Tiki Barber... all the way.
t barber
most scoring formats you should pick barber, however if your using yahoo default then td's are more important. therefore you should pick edge b/c he's going to get more goaline touches.
barber of course
I think you should go with Jenkin's #85 of the GB Packers. But thats only cause I think he's kickass cause he did the Lambeau Leap. Plus, he was their 2nd round draft pick, and he's good..Just like Bubba Franks makes a really good TE.
Neither, actually, cuz Tiki won't score and the Edge has no offensive line in front of him---take the younger Rudi JOhnson or Lamant Jordan instead
t barber no doubt