Who's the better first round choice (8th Pick), Marion Barber or Randy Moss?

I draft in 10 minutes and I just found out I have the 8th pick. At #8, I'd love to get Tom Brady, but most have him going at 6.





So that leaves me with Marion Barber (RB, Average Draft Position 10.02) or Randy Moss (WR, ADP 10.10).





I snagged Moss last year round 3, pick 1 and he was by far my best player. But last year, he was playing for his contract and teams did not have much luck covering him. Now, teams know how to plan around Moss (thanks to the Giants).





Barber, on the other hand, is the main back in Dallas now. Sure, Felix Jones will help share the load, but Barber is definitely more Goal Line and should get the ball at least 20 times a game now.





Who is the better pick? I personally like Barber, but many people are saying Moss is better without question.





What do I do?Who's the better first round choice (8th Pick), Marion Barber or Randy Moss?
Easy answer. It depends who you pick in later rounds. If you think at pick 8/4 i believe, that you can get substansial running backs later in the draft, take moss. I really don't like barber because he now has Jones fighting for carries. But,if you need a solid RB and want to take WR's later choose BarberWho's the better first round choice (8th Pick), Marion Barber or Randy Moss?
Moss is a touchdown machine. But teams have a better understanding of how to cover him now. I would go with Barber. The guy's a monster and now Julius Jones isn't stealing carries from him anymore.
Both are very good... there's more talent out there at WR than RB, so if it was me I'd pick RB. But Moss can put up some major points... this is a no-lose pick.